The Kerala court in India, after seventeen months since the sinking of the MSC Elsa 3 off the western coast of the state, has granted permission to resume negotiations with MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company. This decision was made following a temporary suspension imposed on a committee of government officials.
Details of the Sinking and Its Impacts
The MSC Elsa 3 sank approximately 14.6 nautical miles off the coast of Kerala, negatively impacting the local fishing industry. Reports of containers and their contents, including chemicals and microplastics, washing ashore have emerged. Additionally, rescue teams have undertaken cleanup efforts to prevent oil leaks from the ship. However, concerns about potential pollution continue.
Negotiations and Legal Claims
In June 2025, the Kerala court had halted negotiations with MSC and its insurance companies, requesting a maritime claim from the government. MSC is attempting to limit its liability to approximately $14.8 million, while the Kerala government has claimed compensation amounting to ₹9,531 crore (about $1.1 billion). Under court order, MSC has provided a bond of $133 million.
On October 27, the court mandated the committee to resume negotiations for compensation. These negotiations will include remediation costs, economic damages, and harm to the environment and fishing community. The purpose of forming this committee has been stated as resolving the case "without unnecessary delay." The Indian government has raised no objections to resuming negotiations, but the committee is not authorized to sign a final agreement or binding contract. The details of these agreements must still be approved by the court.
The MSC Elsa 3 still contains containers within it, and the parties are discussing the ongoing environmental pollution caused by these containers. In addition to the fuel on board, documentation indicates the presence of chemicals including calcium carbide and rubber chemicals in the ship's cargo. Officials have suggested to the court that there may be a need to remove the remaining containers from the wreck. MSC's lawyers stated in court that 437 tons of fuel and pollutants have already been removed from the ship, and attempts to lift the sunken containers may cause them to break and release more pollution.
The next court session regarding the MSC Elsa 3 is scheduled for November 24.
Read more: Sanctions on Tankers in the Strait of Hormuz and Changes in Trade Routes
